BOUNDARIES

Articles in respect of Wall Boundaries

Tree Boundaries
Hedge Boundaries
Shrub Boundaries

Tree Boundaries

Stacks Image 351

Trees Growing along one side of the Boundary

Stacks Image 554

Tree Straddling a Boundary

Boundary Trees and the Common Law

One Side of the Boundary

Where the boundary is indicated by a line of trees or shrubs the said trees or shrubs belong to the owner of the land upon which they are growing. This is so even where the branches, roots, fruit or leaves overhang, although the adjoining land owner has the right to cut the same back, so long as in doing so the tree is not destroyed.

Where the Title Register and Title Plan clearly indicate ownership of the boundary to be one one side only, the centre line would equate with the legal boundary line drawn on the OS map and Title Register. This was affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Fisher v Winch 1939, and followed by Davey v Harrow Corporation 1957.

Both Sides of the Boundary

Subject to evidence to the contrary, where trees or shrubs are astride the boundary the general law of England and Wales is that the boundary passes through the centre of the tree trunks.

However, this may depend on how it came about that the trees straddle the boundary. In such cases the law may be more difficult to determine. However, there is persuasive authority for this in a Canadian case known as Loenig v Goebel 1998. This case was decided by the Saskatchewan Supreme Court.

In this case boundary trees were classified into 3 types, with 3 different outcomes:

Straying Straddle Trees
Consensual Straddle Trees
Voluntary Straddle Trees.



Straying Straddle Trees


Straying Straddle Trees are trees that are planted on one side of the boundary by one owner, with the knowledge that the boundary was within his own property. Over time, the boles of the trees have strayed onto the neighbouring property. Candadian law would regard this as a jointly owned boundary.


Consensual Straddle Trees


Consensual Straddle Trees are deliberately planted by the neighbours upon the property boundary, so that the boles of the trees lay astride of the boundary. It is assumed that the respective neighbours would only do so if they both understood the boundary to be jointly owned.


Voluntary Straddle Trees


Voluntary Straddle Trees have an unknown origin. Where the trees have self-seeded on one side of the boundary but strayed over it, norwithstanding if was not planted by the owner of the land upon which it started out, he would remain liable in damages to the neighbour.


Bent Straddle Trees


A fourth type of Straddle Tree is identified by another Canadian Case, which was decided in the Ontario Supreme Court and known as Hartley v Cunningham 2013. In this case it was decided that a tree whose trunk was on one side of the boundary at ground level, but whose trunk strayed over the boundary as it gained height, was a Straddle Tree, presumably a Strayiing Straddle Tree. This case would also be regarded as persuasive authority but it would not bind the Supreme Court of England and Wales.


Easements of Light


A right of light exists in favour of a property that has enjoyed daylight for the last 20 years or more, and the right allows for the owners to continue to receive that light. That right arises as a result of the Prescription Act 1832 and also the Rights to Light Act 1959. The prescriptive right was recently considered by the Law Commission in 2014, who were considering the question as to whether the prescriptive right should be abolished. Their decision was not to abolish the right. Right to light can only be terminated if it can be shown to be abandoned or if the beneficiary of it consents.

Apple Books

House and Garden Boundaries


The author of the book, House and Garden Boundaries, has more than 25 years experience in the field. The Book is more than 200 pages long, and deals with all aspects of boundary identification. it is fully illustrated and descriptive of all types of boundaries, including ditches & hedges, trees, hedgerows, fences, fence-wall boundaries, non-tidal rivers, non-tidal river islands and streams. The book demonstrates how to find details of express and implied boundaries from the Title Register, Title Plan, Lease, Lease Plan, Conveyancing Deeds, and deed Plans. In addition, there are details of boundary presumptions and boundary fence protocols, all of which are fully illustrated. There is a template for an Informal Boundary Agreement, which can be adapted to each reader's needs. Finally, actual examples of case studies occupy the substantial final chapter of the book.